5194 S Hamilton S, Saylorsburg, PA 18353 (MLS# PM-133337)

5194 S Hamilton S, Saylorsburg, PA 18353

$437,500

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 4 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 3,640 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 26,572 Status: Closed

Current Price: $437,500 List Date: 6/21/2025 Last Modified: 12/04/2025

Overview

Description

'Property is Under Contract & Considering Backup Offers Only at this Time'. Your dream lakefront lifestyle is waiting on the peaceful shores of Saylors Lake Fishing Association! This rare find in the Hamilton Township/Stroudsburg School District offers over 3,100 sq. ft. of renovated living space on nearly ¾ of an acre, with an impressive 73 feet of private lake frontage. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, vacation home, or investment, this retreat blends rustic charm with modern luxury in one of the Poconos' most desirable locations. Step into a sun-drenched open concept design where vaulted ceilings, new hardwood & tile floors & an original stone fireplace with gas insert create a warm, inviting ambiance. The custom kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing granite countertops, central island, and a banquette dining nook, perfect for hosting friends or enjoying Sunday breakfast with a lake view. The flexible 3-5 bedroom layout includes a spacious main-level ... (Read more)

Listing Details MLS# PM-133337

General Property Information

Rooms Total: 11
Bedrooms Total: 4
Bathrooms Total: 2
Bathrooms Full: 2
Above Grade Finished Area: 3140
Below Grade Finished Area: 500
Living Area: 3140
Living Area Source: Estimated
Below Grade Unfinished Area: 500
Building Area Total: 3640
Building Area Source: Estimated
Stories: 2
Stories Total: 2
Year Built: 1902
Year Built Source: Public Records
Fireplace YN: Yes
Basement YN: Yes
Pool Private YN: No
Spa YN: No
Garage YN: Yes
Attached Garage YN: No
Garage Spaces: Yes
Carport YN: No
Open Parking YN: Yes
Open Parking Spaces: 9
Parking Total: 10
Lot Size Acres: 0.61
Lot Size Dimensions: 169X221X144X73X307
Lot Dimensions Source: Public Records
View YN: Yes
Water Body Access YN: Yes
Water Body Restrictions YN: Yes
Waterfront YN: Yes
Association YN: No
Sign On Property YN: Yes
List Price/SqFt: 137.36
Sold Price/SqFt: 120.19
Bathrooms Half: 0
Above Grade Unfinished Area: 0

Property Features

Special Listing Conditions: Standard Listing Terms: Cash; Conventional; FHA; USDA Loan; VA Loan Disclosures: Deed Restrictions Possession: Close Of Escrow Structure Type: House Current Use: Residential Property Condition: Updated/Remodeled Architectural Style: Bungalow; See Remarks Interior Features: Breakfast Nook; Eat-in Kitchen; Kitchen Island; Granite Counters; Double Vanity; Sauna; Walk-In Closet(s); Open Floorplan; Recessed Lighting; Built-in Features; Ceiling Fan(s); Storage; Other; See Remarks Fireplace Features: Insert; Propane; Masonry Laundry Features: Main Level; Electric Dryer Hookup; Washer Hookup Flooring: Carpet; Tile; Wood Door Features: French Doors; Pocket Door(s); Storm Door(s) Window Features: Double Pane Windows Construction Materials: Vinyl Siding; Other Basement: Full; Exterior Entry; Walk-Out Access; Unfinished; Concrete Foundation Details: Concrete Perimeter Roof: Asphalt Electric: 200+ Amp Service Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s); Central Air Heating: Fireplace(s); Forced Air; Oil Appliances: Electric Range; Refrigerator; Dishwasher; Microwave; Washer; Dryer; Water Heater Security Features: See Remarks Water Source: Public Sewer: On Site Septic Utilities: Phone Connected; Cable Connected; Cable Available; Propane Tank Leased; See Remarks Exterior Features: Balcony; Fire Pit; Lighting; Private Yard; Storage; Other Patio And Porch Features: Patio; Rear Porch; Deck; Covered; See Remarks Fencing: Invisible Parking Features: Garage Faces Side; Parking Pad; On Site; Driveway; Circular Driveway; RV Access/Parking Lot Features: Sloped; Wooded; Paved; Other Road Frontage Type: City Street Road Surface Type: Paved Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road View: Forest; Hills; Other Water Body View: Yes Water Body Type: Lake Water Body Features: Fishing; Dry Dock Water Body Restrictions: See Remarks Water Body Access Type: Association Room Types: Living Room; Dining Room; Kitchen; Primary Bedroom; Primary Bathroom; Bathroom 2; Bathroom 3; Family Room; Bonus Room; Utility Room; Other

Contract Information

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Listing Contract Date: 2025-06-20
Listing Service: Full Service

Location Tax and Legal

County: Monroe
Street Number: 5194
Street Direction Prefix: S
Street Name: Hamilton
Street Direction Suffix: S
City (Post Office): Saylorsburg
State: PA
Postal Code: 18353
Subdivision Name: Saylors Lake

Remarks and Miscellaneous

Public Remarks: 'Property is Under Contract & Considering Backup Offers Only at this Time'. Your dream lakefront lifestyle is waiting on the peaceful shores of Saylors Lake Fishing Association! This rare find in the Hamilton Township/Stroudsburg School District offers over 3,100 sq. ft. of renovated living space on nearly ¾ of an acre, with an impressive 73 feet of private lake frontage. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, vacation home, or investment, this retreat blends rustic charm with modern luxury in one of the Poconos' most desirable locations. Step into a sun-drenched open concept design where vaulted ceilings, new hardwood & tile floors & an original stone fireplace with gas insert create a warm, inviting ambiance. The custom kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing granite countertops, central island, and a banquette dining nook, perfect for hosting friends or enjoying Sunday breakfast with a lake view. The flexible 3-5 bedroom layout includes a spacious main-level primary suite with laundry, while upstairs you'll find an enclosed sun porch, private deck & bonus rooms for guests, office, or creative space. Updates abound: new furnace, central air, hot water heater, oil tank, paved driveway, fresh paint & new flooring. Extra touches like a sauna, outdoor shower, vintage spring house & dual-level lakefront decks make this home truly unforgettable. Outside, entertain on the covered porch, roast marshmallows at the lakeside firepit, or launch your kayak, canoe, or paddleboard right from your own shoreline. Every season is spectacular swim & fish in summer, take in fiery foliage in fall, cozy up by the fireplace in winter & enjoy the rebirth of spring on the water. All of this is just minutes to Routes 33 & 80, with easy access to skiing, hiking, vineyards, restaurants & shopping. Stroudsburg School District adds top-rated education to this unbeatable lifestyle. Your lakefront luxury retreat starts here, don't miss this exceptional value!

Status Change Information

Price Change Timestamp: 2025-09-13T15:18:49Z
Purchase Contract Date: 2025-10-26
Close Date: 2025-12-04
Close Price: 437500

More Information

Property Condition

Year Built Effective: 2015
Updated/Remodeled: Yes

Entry Information

Entry Location: front door

Fireplace Features

Fireplaces Total: Yes
Insert: Yes
Propane: Yes
Masonry: Yes

Room Types

Living Room Level: First
Dining Room Level: First
Kitchen Level: First
Primary Bedroom Level: First
Primary Bathroom Level: First
Bathroom 2 Level: Second
Bathroom 3 Level: Second
Family Room Level: First
Bonus Room Level: First
Utility Room Level: Basement
Other Level: Second
Living Room: Yes
Bathroom 2: Yes
Bathroom 3: Yes
Dining Room: Yes
Bonus Room: Yes
Family Room: Yes
Kitchen: Yes
Other: Yes
Primary Bathroom: Yes
Primary Bedroom: Yes
Utility Room: Yes

Location, Tax, and Legal

Parcel Number: 07.12.1.71
Municipality: Hamilton Township
High School District: Stroudsburg Area
County Tax Amount: 1542.63
Municipal Tax Amount: 39.43
School Tax Amount: 7718.34
Tax Other Annual Assessment Amount: 52.36
Tax Annual Amount: 9352.76
Tax Assessed Value: 281640
Tax Year: 2025
Tax Map Number: 07627709175020
Tax Book Number: 202404629
Tax Page Number: 2645/9747
Deed Recording Date: 2022-11-16
Zoning: C-1- Commercial
Zoning Description: Residential
FEMA Zone: A

Currently Not Used

Furnished: Unfurnished
Year Built Details: The home has had many facelifts since the year built. With kitchen, 1st floor floors, dock and exterior stairs being done within the last few years.

Special Listing Conditions

Standard: Yes

Listing Terms

Cash: Yes
Conventional: Yes
FHA: Yes
USDA Loan: Yes
VA Loan: Yes

Disclosures

Deed Restrictions: Yes

Possession

Close Of Escrow: Yes

Structure Type

House: Yes

Current Use

Residential: Yes

Architectural Style

Bungalow: Yes
See Remarks: Yes

Interior Features

Breakfast Nook: Yes
Eat-in Kitchen: Yes
Kitchen Island: Yes
Granite Counters: Yes
Double Vanity: Yes
Sauna: Yes
Walk-In Closet(s): Yes
Open Floorplan: Yes
Recessed Lighting: Yes
Built-in Features: Yes
Ceiling Fan(s): Yes
Storage: Yes
Other: Yes
See Remarks: Yes

Laundry Features

Main Level: Yes
Electric Dryer Hookup: Yes
Washer Hookup: Yes

Flooring

Carpet: Yes
Tile: Yes
Wood: Yes

Door Features

French Doors: Yes
Pocket Door(s): Yes
Storm Door(s): Yes

Window Features

Double Pane Windows: Yes

Construction Materials

Vinyl Siding: Yes
Other: Yes

Basement

Full: Yes
Exterior Entry: Yes
Walk-Out Access: Yes
Unfinished: Yes
Concrete: Yes

Foundation Details

Concrete Perimeter: Yes

Roof

Asphalt: Yes

Electric

200+ Amp Service: Yes

Cooling

Ceiling Fan(s): Yes
Central Air: Yes

Heating

Fireplace(s): Yes
Forced Air: Yes
Oil: Yes

Water Heater

Electric: Yes

Appliances

Electric Range: Yes
Refrigerator: Yes
Water Heater: Yes
Dishwasher: Yes
Microwave: Yes
Washer: Yes
Dryer: Yes

Security Features

See Remarks: Yes

Water Source

Public: Yes

Sewer

On Site Septic: Yes

Utilities

Phone Connected: Yes
Cable Connected: Yes
Cable Available: Yes
Propane Tank Leased: Yes
See Remarks: Yes

Exterior Features

Balcony: Yes
Fire Pit: Yes
Lighting: Yes
Private Yard: Yes
Storage: Yes
Other: Yes

Patio And Porch Features

Patio: Yes
Rear Porch: Yes
Deck: Yes
Covered: Yes
See Remarks: Yes

Fencing

Invisible: Yes

Parking Features

Garage Faces Side: Yes
Parking Pad: Yes
On Site: Yes
Driveway: Yes
Circular Driveway: Yes
RV Access/Parking: Yes

Lot Features

Sloped: Yes
Wooded: Yes
Paved: Yes
Other: Yes

Road Frontage Type

City Street: Yes

Road Surface Type

Paved: Yes

Road Responsibility

Public Maintained Road: Yes

View

Forest: Yes
Hills: Yes
Other: Yes

Water Body View

Yes: Yes

Water Body Type

Lake: Yes

Water Body Features

Fishing: Yes
Dry Dock: Yes

Water Body Restrictions

See Remarks: Yes

Water Body Access Type

Association: Yes

Room Information

Room Name	Level	Length	Width	Remarks
Living Room	First	14.00	17.00
Dining Room	First	12.00	14.00	Open Concept Area along with Livingroom
Kitchen	First	12.00	17.00
Family Room	First	14.00	14.00
Primary Bedroom	First	14.00	15.00
Primary Bathroom	First	10.00	12.00
Bonus Room	First	9.00	12.00
Bathroom 2	Second	17.00	17.00
Bathroom 3	Second	14.00	20.00
Other	Second	14.00	14.00	Sitting Room with Pellet Stove
Other	Second	12.00	16.00	Rec Room with Title Flooring
Utility Room	Basement	12.00	18.00
Other	Basement	8.00	24.00	storage

Listing Office: Bairo Real Estate - Bartonsville

Last Updated: December - 04 - 2025

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Connect with a Building Expert